Welcome to Pie Heaven

  • Open Tuesday-Saturday
  • 11am to 4pm




See Store for Pricing

Custom Orders & Catering

Building on their 15-year history of collaboration, pastry chef Carolyn Downs and chef Mike Johnson decided three years ago to open a “barbecue and pie place.” When Carolyn started making pies for Sugarfire Smokehouse, she never expected to become so busy that she would need more baking space. So out of necessity Sugarfire Pie was born on October 29, 2014. Sugarfire Pie has a 50's motif with a hint of "Twin Peaks." Featuring seasonal pies, the shop also has a smoked chocolate chip cookie, pie cakes, stack pies, cobblers. hand pies, bourbon balls, anything pie! The shop also serves hand dipped ice cream and pie shakes with a variety of toppings.

Fresh Ingredients
Years of Experience
Timeless Recipes
Sugarfire Flair
Lots of Love

Behind the Pies

Carolyn Downs

Owner / Pastry Chef

Sara Marshall

Manager / Baker

Alice McHugh


Visit Us

SugarFire Pie

9200 Olive Blvd #108
Olivette, MO 63132
Get Directions

(314) 736-6300